Foreword

SMEs and entrepreneurs constitute the backbone of national economies in OECD countries and beyond. In the OECD area, they represent almost the totality of the business population and account for 60% of total employment and between 50% and 60% of value added on average. They are key to strengthening productivity, delivering more inclusive growth and adapting to megatrends such as the new industrial revolution, the changing nature of work and demographic changes.

Financing for SMEs is important at all stages of the business life cycle, in order to enable these firms to start up, develop and grow. Governments around the world have been stepping up efforts to foster a diversified financial offer for SMEs. The OECD’s annual report Financing SMEs and Entrepreneurs: An OECD Scoreboard is an important tool to help governments get their SME finance policies right. By monitoring SME access to debt, asset-based finance and external sources of equity, along with framework conditions and information on policy initiatives, it provides a solid framework and evidence base in this area.

The seventh edition of this annual publication covers 43 countries worldwide and includes data covering the 2007-2016 period. It builds on previous editions with important improvements in methodology and analysis. The study shows that the economic environment has generally improved for SMEs. In 2016, fewer SMEs went bankrupt, continuing the trend which began in 2014. In addition, B2B payment delays and non-performing loans remain low by recent standards. Nonetheless, lending is now down in a majority of countries for which data are available, in some instances due to weak demand for credit and low levels of corporate investment.

This has coincided with an emerging trend of rising volumes of financing instruments used by SMEs as alternatives to bank loans. This is the case for asset-based financing such as leasing and factoring, venture capital investments, and crowdfunding and related online marketplace activities. While these developments are welcome, many SMEs remain over-reliant on straight debt for their external financing needs. The financial crisis underscored the vulnerability of these businesses to changing conditions in the credit market. It also highlighted the limitations of bank debt, especially for innovative fast-growing firms for which equity sources of finance are often more appropriate. In addition, micro-enterprises and start-ups continue to face more financing constraints and would benefit in particular from having access to a diversified set of financing options.

The G20/OECD High-Level Principles on SME Financing call for a two-pronged approach to enhance access to traditional debt finance and enable SMEs to access a broad variety of financing sources to complement bank finance. In this respect, the OECD is supporting countries through the identification of effective approaches for implementation of the Principles.

In recent years, many new initiatives to support financial instruments, other than straight debt, have surfaced. These include the establishment or expansion of venture capital funds, the removal of regulatory barriers and the creation of tax incentives for investors in SMEs. Such measures often seek to target young firms with high growth potential, since these SMEs often encounter particular difficulties in accessing external finance. Financial support is also increasingly complemented with non-financial support.

The latest Scoreboard data suggests that these policies are starting to bear fruit. It will remain crucial to monitor these developments, the risks that they might pose, and, more generally, to better understand SME finance trends in order to underpin the development of appropriate policy responses. The Scoreboard will continue to be a vital tool and to assist policymakers in these areas.

picture

Angel Gurría

OECD Secretary-General

Acknowledgements

This report was produced by the OECD Centre for Entrepreneurship, SMEs, Regions and Cities (CFE), led by Lamia Kamal-Chaoui, Director, as part of the programme of work of the Working Party on SMEs and Entrepreneurship.

The development of Financing SMEs and Entrepreneurs 2018: An OECD Scoreboard is possible thanks to the country experts from participating OECD member and non-member countries, which provided information for the country profiles.

Country expert team

Australia

Andrew Fragomelli

Small Business Policy Division of the Treasury

 

Evan Holley

Small Business Policy Division of the Treasury

Austria

Thomas Saghi

Federal Ministry of Science, Research and Economy

Belgium

Johan Westra

Federal Ministry of Economy, SMEs, Self-employed and Energy

 

Christophe Herinckx

Federal Ministry of Economy, SMEs, Self-employed and Energy

Brazil

Eduardo Andre de Brito Celino

Special Secretary for Micro and Small Enterprises (SEMPE)

 

Carlos Veloso

Special Secretary for Micro and Small Enterprises (SEMPE)

 

Alexandre Monteiro

Special Secretary for Micro and Small Enterprises (SEMPE)

Canada

Richard Archambault

Industry Canada

Chile

Jose Joaquin Fernandez Chicharro

Ministry for the Economy, Development, and Tourism

China

Wu Bao

China Institute for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises

 

Renyong Chi

China Institute for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises

 

Yantai Chen

China Institute for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises

Colombia

Jorge Enrique Motta Llanos

Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Tourism

Czech Republic

Veronika Reek

Ministry of Industry and Trade

Denmark

Ole Jørgensen

Ministry of Business and Growth

William Gram

Ministry of Business and Growth

Estonia

Karel Lember

Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications

Finland

Jari Huovinen

Confederation of Finnish Industries

France

Jean-Pierre Villetelle

Banque de France

 

Marie-Laure Wyss

General Directorate for Competitiveness, Industry and Services

Georgia

David Shiolashvili

Enterprise Georgia

Greece

Timotheos Rekkas

Hellenic Ministry for Development and Competitiveness

Hungary

Zsuzsanna Lakatosné Lukács

Ministry for National Economy

Árpád Ferenc Nagy

Ministry for National Economy

Ireland

Marja-Kristina Akinsha

Department of Finance, Banking Policy Division

 

Eric Gargan

Department of Finance, Banking Policy Division

Israel

Nir Ben-Aharon

Small and Medium Business Agency, Ministry of Economy

Italy

Sabrina Pastorelli

Bank of Italy

Japan

Daiji Hotihama

Small and Medium Enterprise Agency, Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry

Kazakhstan

Yermek Abdebekov

Damu Entrepreneurship Fund

 

Dinara Tazhenova

Department for Entrepreneurship, Ministry of National Economy

 

Assel Yebemgediyeva

Center for Trade Policy Development

Korea

Changwoo Nam

Korea Development Institute

Latvia

Agita Nicmane

Ministry of Economics

Luxembourg

Cesare Riilio

National Institute for Statistics and Economic Studies

Mexico

Ivan Ornelas Diaz

INADEM

 

Liliana Reyes Castrejon

INADEM

Malaysia

Karunajothi Kandasamy

SME Corporation Malaysia

 

Rafiza Bt. Abdul Rajab

SME Corporation Malaysia

 

Suhailes Shamsuddin

SME Corporation Malaysia

 Netherlands

Liselotte Van Thiel

Ministry of Economic Affairs

New Zealand

Miriam Mathews

Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment

Norway

Eirik Knutsen

Statistics Norway

 

Øystein Jørgensen

Ministry of Trade, Industry and Fisheries

Poland

Pawel Maryniak

Ministry of Economic Development

Portugal

Nuno Goncalves

Office of the Secretary of State of Economy and Regional Development

Russia

Evgeny Tcherbakov

Vnesheconombank

Serbia

Maja Gavrilovic

National Bank of Serbia

 

Ana Ivkovic

National Bank of Serbia

Slovak Republic

Tatiana Smoroňová

National Agency for SME Development

Slovenia

Tine Janžek

Bank of Slovenia

South Africa

Peter Makgetsi

National Treasury, Financial Sector Policy Unit

Spain

Víctor García-Vaquero

Bank of Spain

Sweden

Andreas Kroksgård

Swedish Agency for Growth Policy Analysis

Switzerland

Samuel Turcati

State Secretariat for Economic Affairs

Thailand

Davina Kunvipusilkul

Bank of Thailand

Turkey

Ufuk Acar

KOSGEB

 

Utku Macit

Ministry of Science, Industry and Technology

United Kingdom

Asad Ghani

British Business Bank

 

Matt Adey

British Business Bank

United States

Giuseppe Gramigna

Small Business Administration

The development of the Scoreboard benefits from the inputs of Delegates of the OECD Working Party on SMEs and Entrepreneurship, chaired by Alejandro Gonzalez Hernandez, and members of its Informal Steering Group on SME and Entrepreneurship Financing, chaired by Professor Salvatore Zecchini. Richard Archambault (Industry Canada), Martin Brassell (Consultant), Asad Ghani (British Business Bank), Luis Ángel Maza Lasierra (European Committee of Central Balance Sheet Data Offices), Jean-Louis Leloir (European Association of Mutual Guarantee Societies) and Valentina Nigro (Central Bank of Italy) provided input for boxes on timely issues. Helmut Kraemer-Eis (European Investment Fund) and Andrew McDonald (European Bank for Reconstruction and Development) prepared annexes to the country profiles. Data provided by Tania Ziegler (Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance), and comments from Gianluca Riccio (OECD Business and Industry Advisory Committee) are gratefully acknowledged.

This report was prepared by Kris Boschmans and Lora Pissareva, Policy Analysts, OECD Centre for Entrepreneurship, SMEs, Regions and Cities, SME and Entrepreneurship Division (CFE/SMEE), under the supervision of Miriam Koreen (Deputy Director and Head of Division, CFE/SMEE). Sebastian Schich, Economist, OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs, Financial Markets, Insurance and Pensions Division prepared the thematic chapter. The report benefited from substantive inputs from Naima Smaini (CFE/SMEE). Masaaki Komatsu, Rhea Subramanya and Bénjamin Vargha (Trainees, CFE) made statistical contributions to the report. Heather Mortimer-Charoy provided technical support.